Ranger and Morelli Cast For Stephanie Plum Movie

Ever since I first heard that this movie is happening, I’ve been impatiently waiting to find out who Stephanie Plum’s leading men would be.  I really do dig Katherine Heigl as Stephanie and was really worried that they would go all wrong with the casting of Ranger and Morelli.  I was also keen to see if, by some slim chance, they went with my choices, but no such luck.

That doesn’t mean it’s all bad though… let’s have a little look-see at who will be playing these two men that are so near and dear to our hearts.

JOE MORELLI

morelli

Wikipedia description of the character:

Joe Morelli is Stephanie’s on-and-off boyfriend, a former bad boy turned vice cop. He is also known as Officer Hottie or the Italian Stallion. Her history with Morelli started with a “choo choo” incident when she was six. At the age of sixteen, Stephanie lost her virginity to Morelli in the Tasty Pastry shop behind the éclair stand, after which he never called (but left quite a few flattering messages in bathroom and stadium walls around town). Three years later she saw Morelli and ran over him with her father’s Buick, breaking his leg. A few years later in One for the Money Morelli was suspected of murder and was her first FTA, and Stephanie chased him around town, much to his annoyance….

At various times, both Stephanie and Morelli have seriously considered marriage, but never at the same time. They both know they’re not ready for commitment, but often comment on the idea together and have lived together more than once. Their relationship runs cold as a result of many arguments – usually over her job (She’s been known to stress Morelli enough that he tends to takes Rolaids & Maalox and tells her that he is quickly deteriorating because of her) and they eventually lead to her relationship with Ranger. Being that both were born & bred in Trenton, whatever happens to/around her usually has a number of others calling Morelli to inform him – cars being blown, bodies being found, etc. He’s said that he doesn’t even need to listen to the radio anymore; he knows she’s always involved (usually by some illegal means) and that he always gets calls about her and the latest situation she’s in.

Afraid I’ll have to cut it there as anything else will just spoil it for those of you who aren’t familiar with the story.

Morelli will be played by Jason O’Mara, who is most well known for his leading role in Life on Mars. I have never watched it as I’m not a big fan of shows that originate from trying to rip off really intelligently written British shows, but well… he looks cute enough.  Not exactly what I had in mind for Morelli, but I can see a faint glimmer of it there.  I somehow imagined him to be the real black haired, dark, Italian type, but my choice was Jeffrey Dean Morgan and he doesn’t exactly fit that description either.

I’m not screaming for joy here but I’m not particularly bothered by it either.  It can still go either way for me and I won’t know until I actually see him in the film.  Although, I may set aside my hatred for watered down American versions of British shows and watch Life on Mars, purely for research purposes.  I will have to get back to you on that.

RANGER

ranger2

Wikipedia description of the character:

Ranger is Stephanie’s fellow bounty hunter and tutor and sometimes known as Batman because of his mysterious ways. Ranger is Cuban-American, with mocha latte skin that can only be described as yum, always wears black or camo green, and drives a rotation of very expensive black cars (Stephanie has lingering questions about the origin of Ranger’s car-supply, but he will only say ‘Don’t ask’). He is the C.E.O. of RangeMan, Inc., a security company (among other things).

Stephanie’s relationship with Ranger, somewhere between boyfriend/girlfriend and teacher/pupil, provides much of her day-to-day stress, along with the almost constant threat of car bombing. Ranger says he loves Stephanie “in his own way” but isn’t the marrying type. Even if she is on with Morelli, it doesn’t stop Ranger from kissing or flirting with her, nor does she do much to discourage his advances. Regardless of his rivalry with Morelli, he has said that “Morelli is a good man” and is the marrying type Stephanie wants. Ranger does high-dollar or high-risk recovery for Vinnie, and sometimes lends Stephanie a hand with some of the more dangerous or slippery FTAs. He often assigns employees to guard or track her when she is in serious danger. Ranger “bleeds money” every time Stephanie requires protection, which is frequently; she minds, but he doesn’t so much – she actually appears as a line item in his budget (where she’s listed under “entertainment”).

As a result of him often coming to her aid or rescue, she has built up quite a tab with him and he has said that one day, he will collect.

Ranger will be played by Daniel Sunjata, who is most famous for his role as the hottie Franco Rivera on Rescue Me.   As for him playing Ranger? Two words… YES PLEASE!!!!!

I challenge you to watch Rescue Me and not think this man was carved out of a piece of heaven itself.  He is HOT!  He can play it cool and he can definitely play a ladies man, as I’m sure whoever came up with the term ladies man obviously met Franco Rivera!  Given the appropriate wardrobe and a good script, he CAN be Ranger, I’m certain of it.   To be honest, I’m not sure why I hadn’t come up with him myself when I was thinking of possibilities.  I think because I imagined Ranger to be harder, someone with a bit more of a rough look or perhaps having played more ‘fighty’ roles in the past (hence my choosing Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson initially), but I think he can do it.  We’ve just not seen him in that kind of role yet, or I haven’t at least.

As with Heigl, I am 100% behind Sunjata as Ranger.  The jury is still out on the Morelli casting, I will have to look into the actor a bit more before I can say either way.

I’m excited about this, really friggin’ excited!  The more castings that happen and the closer the movie comes to being a reality, the more eager I am to see it.  Especially now after seeing these castings.  That said, it could all go to shit if they don’t choose wisely for Grandma Mazur and Lula, as they are pretty central characters that are loved by all.  Get those two wrong and they may as well not even bother making the film.

I will be keeping my eyes peeled for any casting news in regards to those two, for sure, but in the meantime… what do YOU think of these guys playing our leading men??

Check Also

TV Review: My Unexpected Love Affair With The Neighbors

One thing about TV is that it can sometimes surprise you.  Sometimes you are so …

Movie Review: One For The Money

Ok, this has been a long time coming but I think I’m finally able to …

245 comments

  1. ranger: dwayne johnson
    morelli: chris evans

  2. I am sooooo disappointed that they have picked Heigl for the role. What a mistake. She always plays the same character. She is NOT a Jersey girl. Next they will pick Beyonce for Lula.

  3. Lets face it ladies, no one will be able to play Stephanie, Morelli and Ranger to any of our liking. The perfect Stephanie, Morelli and Ranger are already made…..in our own minds.
    Fantastic books made to movies never really works. They should of just left well enough alone.

    • I agree we all have the perfect guy or girl in mind for each character. I can conjure up the perfect Ranger in my head and no one could live up to him in real life. (there are some that could come close however.) Hopefully our love for the books won’t be ruinned by the movie.

  4. For me, it’s so far, so good! I would be happy with complete unknowns for Grandma and Lula… I just want them to have a great script and be able to act. And dear God, I hope they cast Bob right!

  5. Ok so I’m thinking Danny Devito for Vinny; or Joe Pesci.

  6. Let me be the first to say that Jason O’Mara will be terrific as Morelli.

    No, he doesn’t look Italian but I care less about that than whether or not he’s sexy (which he is), can be funny (which he can be), and whether he can “play” smart enough to be a good detective (which he can). He’s a terrific actor. Life of Mars was pretty good but I’ve seen him in enough other roles where he’s the most interesting thing on screen. I think the most important factor is whether or not there is a big difference between he and Ranger ~ and there is.

    I’m not in love with Katherine Heigl as Stephanie but then I never cared for Grey’s Anatomy. And I never saw Sandra Bullock or Reese Witherspoon as Stephanie either as they’re not the right “type” at all. So maybe Katherine Heigl IS the right one… and really, as long as they didn’t cast Jennifer Aniston, I will at least go see the movie.

    And while I love Betty White as Grandma Mazur, that seems a little too predictable, like “stunt-casting”. We’d be watching “Betty” and not the character.

  7. Oh I got the perfect guy for Ranger,,,, Shemar More of Criminal Minds. Yummmmmmmyyyyyyy

  8. Morelli no good, so many other could of done Morelli what about the actor that played Denny on Greys Anatomy , Betty White ok for Grandma, Monique for LuLu

  9. It’s not bad enough that they’ve cast Katherine Heigl as Stephanie Plum, but to not even attempt to find suitable actors for Ranger and Morelli! Aarrgghhh! Im just so disappointed. I love the series but I WILL NOT be going to see the movie! What was casting on when they were supposed to be working on this movie.

  10. all of the main characters are COMPLETELY WRONG!!!!!!!

  11. I agree that Sandra B would be a better Stephanie but maybe they thought she’s too old. Jason O’Mara for MOrelli could work, he’s definitely a big, hot studly type. But I’m so behind Niecy Nash as Lulu & Cloris Leachman as Grandma Mazur would be perfect. I love Betty & she’s got the attitude but just isn’t scrawny enough to be Grandma. As fine as Sunjata I’m not feeling him for Ranger though, just have to see.
    Just finished Sizzling Sixteen, can’t wait for more.

  12. Ok. Mental imagery is everything for us who love these characters. I can live with Heigl and the guy who’s playing Ranger although I am not familiar with him looks like he can do it. However my mental Morelli is more like Christopher Melloni

  13. I can’t believe they picked Heigl as Stephanie Plum! I am no longer excited about the movie. I would rather see Ashley Judd play Stephanie Plum, The Rock as Ranger, Betty White as Grandma Mazur, Queen Latifiah as Lulu and I am having a hard time with who to pick for Morelli but the guy they picked doesn’t do it for me at all!!

  14. okay i think it is pretty agreeable about RANGER… He was a great choice and boy is that guy HAWT! but for stephanie they made a crapy choice and they prob should have chosen sandra bullock …she is perfect to play the hazard happy stephanie…and we wont even comment on Morelli though you never know this guy might be able to pull it off..

  15. As far as the casting goes I can’t really argue with it. I like Katherine Heigl as Stephanie Plum and I think she will be able to handle the role (this after seeing her in “The Ugly Truth”). Daniel Sunjata seems to be a good choice for Ranger (even if I haven’t seen “Rescue Me”), especially if they add the longish hair that he seems to favor. If he can get that air of mystery that Ranger has he’ll be a good fit.

    As for Morelli…I have to admit that Morelli is essentially my dream man, so I will have a hard time with ANYONE being cast in that role. Jason O’Mara might do it — I saw a couple of episodes of “Life On Mars” and enjoyed his performance. Of course, I always had Joe Flanigan (John Sheppard from Sci-Fi’s “Stargate: Atlantis”) in my head for Morelli, since he has the dark hair, eyes and somewhat dark complexion and can pull of the rogue-jerk-that-still-cares character well (in my opinion).

    But of course, that is just my opinion… :)

  16. Ok, so Sandra Bullock would have made a great Stephanie I agree but Heigl isn’t so bad. Ranger, they did pretty good. I still need to see his body more to see if he really fits the part but the face is about what I pictured. Morelli….well is all wrong. He is too old, too round in my opinion. When the books start Morelli and Plum are in their twenties. I picture a young version of Sam Elliot playing Morelli. He needs to be tall and thin but muscular. And he has to look like a million bucks in a pair of wranglers. I guess we’ll just have to deal..the choice has been made. I thought about the Rock for Ranger too but I just can see the Rock portraying a dark and mysterious enough personality to really fit the part. Now Ellen Dow would be the perfect scrawny Grandma Mazur! Picture Ellen pulling out a hand gun and tell me that wouldn’t be perfect!

  17. Sandra Bullock should have been Stephanie!!!

  18. Totally blew it casting Heigl as Stephanie and O’Mara as Morelli. O’Mara is not handsome enough and too old. Sunjata is a good pick for Ranger. He’s hot. This shouldn’t have been that hard people! A hot looking Italian in his late 20s to play Morelli? They should have picked unknowns.

  19. I think Hiegl will do great! Was hoping for Mark Wahlberg to be Morelli….so I’m not impressed with the choice! Also hoping for Dwayne Johnson to be Ranger! Oh well, I’m still excited to see it!

    • I, too, thought of Mark Wahlberg for Morelli. Of the 3 main characters cast here, the only one I can see if Ranger. Heigl is COMPLETELY wrong for Stephanie. Who the hell cast her? I always picture more of a Marisa Tomei – she’s got the Jersey edge to her, and the comedic timing, tho probably considered too old for the part now. Too bad – she would’ve been great.

      • I agree – Heigl is NOT anywhere even CLOSE to Stephanie Plum! I like her in roles like 27 Dresses, but she doesn’t have the edge needed for this one. I would have liked to see someone like Sandra Bullock in that part.

        Morelli – Also a TOTAL MISS!!!!! Hello – ITALIAN – How hard is it to find a HOT Italian actor in this planet of 6 billion? Honestly!

        Ranger – Not right on, but he is amazingly good looking. So I have hope for him.

        Betty White as Grandma Mazur and Monique as Lula would help this cast A LOT!!

      • What about Marisa Tomei as Connie?

        • I agree that Marisa Tomei would be a good match. Also Dabniel Pino for Morelli and Shemar Moore for Ranger. I think Danny DeVito would be good for Vinnie.

          • Remember Connie is Betty Boopish. Marisa Tomei doesn’t have the body. Danny Devito could work as Vinnie…definitely. Shemar Moore is too African American. Ranger is more Cuban.

  20. Heigl – I’ll wait and see.
    Sunjata – definite possibility.
    O’Mara – I don’t see him. I pictured someone more like Jim Caviezel.

    And what about Lula and Connie? And Vinnie – I see Steve Buscemi as a good possibility.

  21. I picture Keri Russell as Stephanie, Betty White would rock as Grandma Mazur, The Rock as Ranger

    • Oh god I can’t imagine Keri Russell at alllll. No no no. I can get behind Betty White though!

      • robert gitchell

        I see Sandra Bullock as Stephanie and The Rock as Ranger

        • Bullock as Stephanie would be absolutely GREAT and of course The Rock is Ranger. Not sure who this guy for Morelli is but he doesn’t seem good looking enough. Hmmmm

    • I am so completely disappointed with the casting of Ranger. He is supposed to be drop dead gorgeous with sex oozing out his pores, big & powerful too. The Rock was perfect! What is wrong with the powers-that-be? Can’t they take a good long look & say OOPSY, made a bad choice. And Morelli should also be gorgeous & Very 2nd. generation Italian. NOT SO CASTING GODS!! Neither one do a thing for me. I want to watch that movie & wish I was right there looking in their eyes. NOW? YUCK!!!!!

      • I agree with you 100 percent, I was really looking forward to the movie, I have read every book and the casting
        for this movie is the worst ever! Please, Sherry Shepard as Lulu, not sure I will be seeing this movie and I am bummed!

    • Betty White no way, the perfect person for Grandma is Anne Morgan Guilbert. She played Millie on the Dick Van Dyke show and Yetta on the Nanny! Perfect.

  22. I’m so cross at Heigl being cast I forgot to add…the actor for Ranger is rather good. Morelli is from an Italian family and the Italian heritage is a continual link throughout all the books? Not sure about this one. Who would be a better Stephanie?

  23. Heigl is wrong wrong wrong for Stephanie. We all love the Stephanie character – she is so likeable. Katherine is simply unlikeable in person and her previous movies are all stinkers. Oh and she can’t act either. Can fans unite to start a petition to get her uncast?

  24. Not crazy about O’Mara, not sure who would have been better, but certainly an Italian actor! Sunjata could do a great Ranger, lips a little thicker than I imagined, but you can’t please every one. Heigl is all wrong! Way too tall is all you have to say. Hair can be dyed, make-up can do wonders, but you can’t cut her legs off! If Niecy Nash isn’t cast as Lula and Ann Morgan Guilbert (Yetta on the Nanny) isn’t cast as Grandma Mazur, don’t know if I’ll bother to go…

  25. Heigl is all wrong for Steph regardless of the fact they cast her…BIG mistake! She’s blonde, not edgy enough and too tall at 5′ 9″.
    Sunjata should make a good Ranger.
    O’Mara not so much! Not handsome enough. Colin Farrel would have been a better choice and with the dark eyes and all would have better fit the description.

    • I agree. She is all WRONG. I would have liked to see Lauren Graham…

    • I think Morelli is all wrong I always pictured eddie Cahill as the tough cop not to stero type him, but ranger casting could work, I always had the image of someone like Lou Diamond Philips. But I am with the rest if the other main characters are matched then the whole dyamic will not be right. It’s not just lula and the plum family, it’s the little roles as Joyce and mooner etc who help her along the way.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.